A Train in Winter

An Extraordinary Story of Women, Friendship, and Resistance in Occupied France

Moorehead, Caroline

Book - 2011
Average Rating: 3.5 stars out of 5.
A Train in Winter
Print
Baker & Taylor
Combines original sources, archival research, and personal interviews to relate the story of 230 women of the French Resistance who were captured and imprisoned by the Gestapo outside of Paris before being transported to Auschwitz.

HARPERCOLL
In January 1943, 230 women of the French Resistance weresent to the death camps by the Nazis who had invaded and occupied theircountry. This is their story, told in full for the first time—a searing andunforgettable chronicle of terror, courage, defiance, survival, and the powerof friendship. Caroline Moorehead, a distinguishedbiographer, human rights journalist, and the author ofDancing to the Precipiceand Human Cargo, brings to life an extraordinary story that readers ofMitchell Zuckoff’sLost in Shangri-La, ErikLarson’s In the Garden of Beasts, and Laura Hillenbrand’sUnbrokenwill find an essential addition to our retelling of the history of WorldWar II—a riveting, rediscovered story of courageous women who sacrificedeverything to combat the march of evil across the world.

Baker
& Taylor

Combining original sources, archival research and in-depth personal interviews, this riveting narrative follows the 230 women of the French Resistance who, imprisoned by the Gestapo outside of Paris, turned to each other, finding solace and strength in friendship. (This book was previously listed in Forecast. 25,000 first printing.

Publisher: New York : HarperCollins, c2011
ISBN: 9780061650703
0061650706
Branch Call Number: 940.5336 M
Characteristics: 374 p. : ill., maps ; 24 cm.

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

Jan 08, 2015
  • Liber_vermis rated this: 4 stars out of 5.

Although this historical account of (often) arbitrary arrest, harsh punishment, torture and malnutrition occurs during the Second World War there are loud echoes with contemporary events in the Near East and central Asia. Can we learn from history or must we repeat the mistakes of the past? This gripping story offers great insight on the human condition.

Mar 27, 2014
  • Edgarmole rated this: 3 stars out of 5.

This is very valuable as a book of research; as a book for general readers it has too much background information, the central part of the book is very interesting. Although the events are grim, the author shows the human side of the women's experiences. Actually it felt like a more extreme version of how my uncle, who was in a combat airplane during the war, experienced civilian life as a pale half-life, compared to his vivid and comradely experiences with his Army buddies.

Oct 15, 2013
  • wmtlady rated this: 2.5 stars out of 5.

Book is extremely well researched but fails to engage the reader with the women survivors; it fails to move from research to a fluid narration.

May 31, 2013
  • WVMLStaffPicks rated this: 4 stars out of 5.

This book shows the French Resistance from the perspective of women from all over France, focusing on 8-10 of the 230 women who were on Le Convoi des 31000. This train with women aged 16-44 was the only train in the entire four years of the occupation to take women from the French Resistance to the Nazi Death Camps. A story of danger, hardship, intimacy, friendship and survival, this is a riveting, sweeping story that continues after the war to follow the lives of these remarkable women.

Mar 25, 2013
  • agbookclub2 rated this: 2.5 stars out of 5.

This was an Angus Glen book club title for 2012. This book was well researched and the subject matter was good; however, the story was hard to read and to follow along with. There were too many characters to really connect to the book. Most people counld not finish the book.

Aug 17, 2012
  • villapark rated this: 2 stars out of 5.

I just couldn't finish reading this one. I liked the setting and story but I was lost in the details. There were too many characters and plot lines for me to follow.

Apr 07, 2012
  • floy rated this: 3.5 stars out of 5.

Although the French government cooperated with the Germans when the Nazis took over France in WWII and although many French were indifferent to the fate of Jews, gypsies, homosexuals, and others deemed undesirable by the Nazis, there was a hard core of resistance in France. This book is the story of some of the French women who were part of that resistance - they had been couriers of messages, printers of posters, guides for those needing to get out of the country, and many offered their homes as shelters for those who needed concealment to survive. All of these things were illegal and the perpetrators subject to imprisonment or death at the hands of the Nazis. Although many in the resistance remained undetected, this particular group ended up being sent to concentration camps - some were exterminated, some died of illnesses or starvation, a few survived. Those who outlived the war credited their survival to their age (usually 20s or 30s), general good health and, most of all, the solidarity the women felt which gave them the will to live in spite of the immense difficulties in doing so.

The Nazis in France defied international rules on the treatment of POWs by declaring that for every German soldier killed by the French resistance, they would kill 50-100 French people being held hostage in internment camps and other facilities. The French prisoners, awaiting their deaths by firing squads or the guillotine, would sing the French national anthem, the Marseillaise, until the last voice was extinguished. Soon a tradition developed - French resistance prisoners would sing the anthem whenever they were taken by the Nazis from places of incarceration to places of hard labor to the places of their deaths to give themselves strength and remind themselves of their purpose. Reading about the singing reminded me of the use of song in the American civil rights movement.

I was surprised to learn how the women spent their time in the camps when they weren't forced to work. The French resistance women stuck together and offered classes to share their knowledge with each other. There were classes on political history, philosophy, foreign languages, and even re-enactments of theatrical plays. Being distracted by such discussions and activities gave them some relief from the onslaught of horror. One commandant at Auschwitz enjoyed classical music and an orchestra of prisoners was formed. It sounds unbelievable but they played Strauss for the prisoner work crews as they left and returned from their worksites to the camps each day.

Only 49 of the 230 French resistance women survived the war. 34 of the 49 were Communists who had dedicated themselves to fighting the Nazis and who were strengthened by their steadfast belief in the Resistance. Their solidarity with each other provided a life support that many of the other incarcerated women lacked. Sadly, after the war there was recrimination. The collaborators were scorned and sometimes imprisoned, the Jews were disparaged for allegedly not fighting back, and some of the leaders of the French Resistance achieved political power but overall there was a great deal of denial of French complicity in the extermination of Jews. As recently as 1980 a poll of French people between 18 & 44 found that 34% believed the existence of gas chambers had not been sufficiently verified.

The surviving French resistance women returned home but often were unhappy in the new normality of their post-war lives. They suffered from survivor's guilt. They were racked with memories that could never be forgotten. They missed the solidarity with their friends during the most intense life/death situation of their lives. They found that their families and neighbors couldn't really relate to what had happened to them. Some lapsed into silence, rarely speaking of those years of captivity when they nearly died.

Mar 13, 2012

After reading the reviews on the novel, i decided to do a quick read before checking it out of the library. As many of you have mentioned, the writing is very dry and difficult to follow- likely due to the manner in which it is edited. Im a huge fan of war lit, but couldn't get myself to get into the book. The book was left on the shelf!

Feb 08, 2012
  • gilby1228 rated this: 1 stars out of 5.

I totally agree with Jeanie123, part one was soooo difficult to get through that I gave up. I'll give it another try one day but just couldn't get past part one. I'm sure there's a great story in there somewhere.

Feb 01, 2012
  • jeanie123 rated this: 3 stars out of 5.

I agree with the comment that this book simply cries out for editing. In fact, I myself cried out "are there no editors?' several times. Part One is excruciatingly tedious as it introduces us to each of the women. Apparently the only noteable facts that the author could find to describe them was their fathers' occupations which was usually irrelevant and added nothing to the story. It is only in Part Two that "the story" begins. I realize that this is non-fiction, but I really feel that there was a great story to tell here, but the writer really missed the mark. There were enough redeeming moments, however, to keep me reading until the end.

View All Comments

Age

Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add a Notice

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Find it at NYPL

  Loading...

Other Formats

Buy It Now

Support your library, keep it forever!

View Purchase Options Learn more about this program

Your Cart

Hello! We noticed you have the following items in your cart right now:

If you'd still like to purchase the items you have in your cart, you can do that now.

You'll be able to purchase your eBook after you have checked out your current cart.

A Train in Winter
Moorehead, Caroline
A Train in Winter

To continue with your eBook purchase immediately, you can clear your cart by clicking below.

All items will be removed from your cart.


I'd like to keep browsing! I'll decide later.

Explore Further


Browse the Shelf

Subject Headings


Recommendations

  Loading...
[]
[]